Winco 12-Inch Seamless Pizza Screen Best Overall
- Design
- Seamless aluminum mesh
- Diameter
- 12 in
- Weight
- 3.52 oz
- Max Temperature
- 550 °F
Twelve inches is the number that settles most of this category. A 12-inch screen clears the rack in a full-size range, drops into many countertop ovens, and bakes a pie that feeds two or three, and of the singles here this Winco is the one we recommend first. It's a seamless disc of aluminum rated to 550 °F, with a one-year manufacturer's warranty and the plain, unglamorous look of something bought from a restaurant supply house. That plainness is the appeal: no coating to wear through, nothing to assemble, nothing to fail.
The open mesh lets steam out of the base while heat comes straight up through it. We built pies directly on the screen and set it on a middle rack, with no peel, no cornmeal on the oven floor, and no stone to preheat for an hour, and the underside browned evenly instead of steaming soft the way it does on a solid pan. At 3.52 ounces it's easy to move with one hand, and the seamless edge gives the dough no lip to catch on when you slide a pie on.
Bare aluminum is not nonstick, and this screen makes that plain: dough laid on dry can grab at the rim and along the mesh. A thin wipe of oil or a dust of semolina settles it, so we treat that as part of the process rather than a flaw. Cleanup is the part that takes planning. Hand wash only, and cheese that drops through the mesh needs a soak before a brush will move it.
If your pies run bigger than 12 inches, go up to the New Star. If you're cooking several at once, a multipack makes more sense. For everyone else this is the screen to start with, and it costs little enough that a second one is an easy addition, so the next pie can be built while the first bakes.
What We Like
- Right size for most full-size and countertop ovens
- Open mesh browns the base evenly
- No coating to chip or wear through
Worth Noting
- Hand wash only; cheese sticks in the mesh
The screen we recommend first: 12 inches of seamless aluminum that fits most ovens, browns a base evenly, and has no coating to wear out.
Check Latest Price