Cuisinart 14-Inch Pizza Pan Best Overall
- Diameter
- 14 inches
- Material
- Aluminized steel
- Care
- Dishwasher safe
- Surface
- Perforated nonstick
Holes in the bottom of a pan are not a gimmick. They let steam out from under the dough, which is the difference between a base that browns and one that sits in its own moisture and goes pale. We put the Cuisinart at the top of this list because it does that job at 14 inches, the size that fits nearly any home oven, clears a standard rack, and takes a supermarket frozen pie with a little room left over. If you want one pan for both a Tuesday-night frozen pizza and a Sunday from-scratch one, start here.
The build is the quiet part. It is heavy-gauge aluminized steel with thick rolled edges, and it sits flat on the rack without flexing when a loaded pie goes in. Rolled rims are the detail we look at first on any pan, because a cut edge is where warping starts and where a nonstick coating begins to fail. The nonstick runs inside and out, so the underside wipes clean as easily as the top.
Two things worth knowing before the first bake. A very wet dough can settle into the perforations, so dust the pan with semolina or cornmeal before you stretch the dough onto it. And cut on a board: the coating will tolerate a pizza wheel for a while, but scoring it once is the start of the flaking you do not want. Neither is a reason to look elsewhere, just part of using it well.
Fourteen inches is also its ceiling. A household that finishes a large pie and wants another should look at the 16-inch GoodCook pair instead. What keeps this one at the top is how little it asks of you: it is one of the least expensive pans here, it is dishwasher safe, and it carries a limited lifetime warranty. Nothing else in this group is this easy to live with.
What We Like
- Perforations dry the bottom for a crisp crust
- Rolled edges hold their shape on the rack
- Releases cleanly and rinses in minutes
Worth Noting
- Too small for pies beyond 14 inches
This is the pan we point most people to first: 14 inches fits most ovens, the holes crisp the bottom, and it releases cleanly enough that cleanup is a rinse.
Check Latest Price