GoodCook AirPerfect Pizza Pan Best Overall
- Size
- 16-inch diameter
- Material
- Carbon steel
- Surface
- Perforated nonstick
- Max Temperature
- 500 °F
The perforated surface is the first thing we notice on the GoodCook AirPerfect, and it is the reason this is our top pick. The holes give steam somewhere to go instead of trapping it under the dough, which is how a pale, soft bottom turns crisp. The cutting guides are a small extra, but a useful one when you are moving a hot pie and do not want to guess at slices. At 16 inches, it handles a large pizza or a frozen pie with room to spare.
We like the nonstick coating for weeknight cooking. Toppings stay put on the way to the oven, and the pizza releases without a fight. The pan is dishwasher safe and rated to 500°F, which covers most home-oven pizza recipes. The trade-off is the footprint: a 16-inch pan needs a wide rack and clearance from the oven walls, so measure before you buy if you have a compact range. We also treat the surface gently and skip metal cutters directly on it.
What it is not is a deep-dish pan. The rim is shallow, so a thick Chicago-style pie belongs in a different pan. For the money, this is the easiest recommendation in the group for anyone who wants a crisp, round pizza without buying a separate stone or steel. If you mostly bake for two, the smaller Wilton is the more sensible fit; if you want a pan that feels heavier in hand, the USA Pan is the step up.
What We Like
- Perforated surface promotes a crisp bottom
- Nonstick coating releases pizza cleanly
- Cutting guides make even slices easier
Worth Noting
- Can warp at high heat
We recommend the AirPerfect as the default steel pizza pan for crisp round pies, thanks to its perforated surface, easy release, and forgiving price.
Check Latest Price