Best Cookie Scoop Size

For most home bakers, the best cookie scoop size is a #40 scoop, which holds about 1½ tablespoons of dough. It makes the cookie most recipes have in mind: about 2½ to 3 inches across once baked, close to the "rounded tablespoon" that classic chocolate chip recipes call for.

Brands often sell this as a "medium" scoop. The OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop is the best-known example. If you want a second size, add a #20 (about 3 tablespoons) for big, bakery-style cookies.

Most scoops, also called dishers, are stamped with a number such as 20, 40 or 60. The number tells you how many level scoops make one quart. A #40 scoop fills a quart in 40 scoops; a #20 does it in 20, so each scoop is twice as big.

That means the numbers run backward: the bigger the number, the smaller the scoop. The system comes from commercial kitchens, where cooks portion food by the quart, and it is the most reliable way to compare scoops across brands.

Some scoops have a colored handle instead of, or as well as, a number. Commercial makers mostly share a color code (for example, gray for #8 and purple for #40), but it isn't universal, so read the number or the capacity.

Capacities are approximate. Real scoops vary a little by maker, and a heaped scoop holds more than a level one.

Scoop number Tablespoons Ounces (volume) Baked cookie Good for
#100 2 teaspoons ⅓ oz 1½ to 2 in Mini cookies, truffles
#70 about 2¾ teaspoons ½ oz about 2 in Small cookies, cookie platters
#60 1 tablespoon ½ oz 2 to 2½ in Shortbread, small chocolate chip
#50 about 1⅓ tablespoons ⅔ oz about 2½ in Everyday drop cookies
#40 about 1½ to 1⅔ tablespoons ¾ oz 2½ to 3 in The standard home cookie
#30 2 tablespoons 1 oz about 3 in Larger cookies, meatballs
#24 about 2⅔ tablespoons 1⅓ oz 3 to 3½ in Big cookies, muffins
#20 about 3 tablespoons 1½ to 1¾ oz 3½ to 4 in Bakery-style cookies, muffins
#16 ¼ cup 2 oz 4 in + Jumbo cookies, standard muffins
#12 ⅓ cup 2⅔ oz — Large muffins, cupcakes

Small, medium and large are not fixed sizes. One brand's "medium" can be another's "small," so compare the tablespoon or ounce figure on the listing.

Level dough portions for #60, #40 and #20 scoops, approximately 1, 1½ to 1⅔, and 3 tablespoons. A larger scoop number means a smaller portion.
Scoop numbers run in reverse: #20 holds more dough than #40. These are approximate dough volumes, not guaranteed baked-cookie sizes. Select the diagram to view it full size.

Chocolate chip and other drop cookies. A #40 is the standard. For thick, gooey cookies in the style of a bakery, go to a #20 or #16 and bake a minute or two longer.

Small or rich cookies. Shortbread, snickerdoodles, gingersnaps and anything rolled in sugar look neater from a #50 or #60. They bake evenly and a platter looks fuller.

Cookies that spread a lot. Thin, buttery cookies such as lace cookies spread far, so use a smaller scoop than the recipe's finished size suggests and leave extra space between them on the sheet.

Beyond cookies. A #16 portions muffin and cupcake batter into standard tins in one clean motion. A #12 does the same for jumbo tins. A #100 or #70 portions truffles, cake pops and melon balls.

How many sizes do you need

Most home bakers use three sizes at most:

  1. #40 (medium) for everyday cookies. If you only buy one, buy this.
  2. #20 or #16 (large) for big cookies, muffins and cupcakes.
  3. #60 or #70 (small) for small cookies, truffles and portioning fillings.

Sets of three save money but can lock you into a brand's own sizing. Before you buy a set, check that the large scoop is close to ¼ cup if you want to use it for muffins.

Size is the first decision; build decides how long the scoop lasts.

  • A spring-loaded squeeze handle with a sweeper bar that releases the dough. The squeeze style is easier on the hand than the thumb-lever style when you portion several dozen cookies.
  • Stainless steel cup and sweeper. Plastic parts and thin metal break first, usually at the gear that moves the sweeper.
  • A sharp, thin rim that cuts cleanly through cold, stiff dough.
  • Dishwasher-safe is useful, though hand washing keeps the spring working longer.

You can compare scoops we cover in our cookie tools section.

Tips for even cookies

  • Level every scoop against the side of the bowl, or the cookies will vary more than you expect.
  • Chill sticky dough for 30 minutes so it releases cleanly.
  • Weigh one scoop the first time you use a new recipe. If a #40 scoop of your dough weighs about 1 ounce, you'll get the same cookie every time.
  • Dip the scoop in water between scoops for very sticky doughs, such as oatmeal or peanut butter.

Frequently Asked Questions