Dough-Joe Shogun Pizza Steel Best Overall
- Surface
- 15 x 15 in
- Weight
- 24 lb
- Thickness
- 3/8 in
- Seasoning
- Pre-seasoned
Nearly every steel in this guide is a 14-by-16-inch rectangle, and that shape quietly limits the pie you can bake to 14 inches across. The Shogun is a 15-inch square, so a full-size round pizza fits with room to spare. That extra inch is why it earns the top spot: it is the difference between a pizza you split four ways and one you cut into proper slices.
Underneath the shape is 3/8-inch carbon steel, and the mass is the whole point. It soaks up enough heat that a second pie goes on while the first is being sliced, and the bottom still comes out dark and crisp rather than pale. Dough-Joe seasons the surface with flaxseed oil and leaves it matte, which gives steam somewhere to go instead of trapping it under the crust. Our pies have released cleanly every time.
A square also wastes no corners on anything that is not round. A focaccia or a tray of rolls fills it edge to edge in a way a rectangle does not, and the plate is big enough that it becomes the surface you cook on rather than a thing you get out. We noticed the difference most on the second bake of the night, when a thinner plate would still be catching up.
What We Like
- Bakes a full 15-inch round pie
- 3/8-inch plate holds heat for a second bake
- Arrives pre-seasoned with flaxseed oil
- Solid carbon steel will not crack
Worth Noting
- 24 pounds needs two hands and mitts
- Needs about 1.5 inches of clearance all around
We make it our top pick because a 15-inch square bakes the largest round pie here, and the 3/8-inch plate keeps the crust crisp through a second.
Check Latest Price