Best Gifts for Cookie Bakers
The best gifts for cookie bakers make every batch faster and more even. Start with a set of spring-loaded cookie scoops and two heavy, light-colored half sheet pans; nothing gets more use. For the holiday baker, add a cookie press for spritz cookies or cookie stamps. Decorators will appreciate an adjustable rolling pin, good cutters and icing tools.
Here are the best picks, organized by what kind of cookies they bake.
For every cookie baker
- Cookie scoops in two or three sizes. A medium (#40) for everyday cookies, a large (#20) for bakery-style cookies and a small (#60 or #70) for small ones. OXO's Good Grips scoops are a reliable choice. Our guide to cookie scoop size explains the numbers.
- Heavy half sheet pans. Two light-colored aluminum or aluminized steel half sheets, such as Nordic Ware Naturals or USA Pan, bake evenly and don't warp. See baking sheet materials.
- Silicone baking mats. A Silpat on each sheet means no parchment, no sticking and easy cleanup.
- Cooling racks. Two stackable wire racks that fit half sheets give room for big batches.
- A thin, flexible cookie spatula. A thin metal turner slides under soft cookies without breaking them.
- A large mixing bowl. A heavy ceramic Mason Cash bowl doesn't skid and looks great on the counter.
For holiday and spritz cookies
- A cookie press. Load the dough, choose a disk, and press out dozens of spritz cookies in minutes. OXO's Good Grips Cookie Press is popular for its easy lever, and the Italian-made Marcato Biscuits press is a sturdy, all-metal option.
- Cookie stamps. Nordic Ware's cast aluminum stamps press detailed designs into shortbread and sugar cookies.
- Embossed rolling pins. Carved pins roll patterns across the dough, from snowflakes to florals. See the types of rolling pins.
- Cookie tins. Pretty tins for gifting, so their cookies can go out the door in style.
For cut-out and decorated cookies
- An adjustable rolling pin. Rings set the thickness, so every cookie bakes the same. The Joseph Joseph Adjustable Rolling Pin is a common choice.
- Quality cookie cutters. Sturdy, sharp-edged cutters, such as Ann Clark's tinplate steel sets, cut cleanly and keep their shape.
- Decorating supplies. Piping bags, small round tips, squeeze bottles, a scribe tool for royal icing, and a set of gel food colors.
- A cookie decorating turntable. A small turntable makes piping borders easier.
For serious cookie bakers
- A digital scale. Weighing flour gives the same cookie every time. The Escali Primo is a reliable classic.
- A stand mixer or powerful hand mixer. Creaming butter and sugar properly makes a real difference. A KitchenAid hand mixer works well for small batches; see our stand mixers section for larger ones.
- High-quality ingredients. Good vanilla, European-style butter, flaky salt and chocolate in bar form (not just chips).
Cookbooks for cookie lovers
- Dorie's Cookies by Dorie Greenspan. More than 160 recipes, from simple drop cookies to elegant French sablés.
- Sally's Cookie Addiction by Sally McKenney. Friendly, reliable recipes with clear steps.
- BraveTart by Stella Parks. Precise versions of classic American cookies, including homemade versions of famous store-bought ones.
How to choose
- Weekend cookie baker: scoops, sheet pans and a silicone mat.
- Holiday baker: a cookie press, stamps and tins.
- Decorator: an adjustable rolling pin, cutters and icing tools.
- Experienced baker: a scale, a cookbook and premium ingredients.
You can compare scoops, presses and cutters in our cookie tools section.
Frequently Asked Questions
Even portions and even baking. Cookie scoops and heavy, light-colored sheet pans make the biggest difference.
For anyone who bakes spritz cookies at the holidays, yes. A good press makes dozens of uniform cookies in minutes.
An adjustable rolling pin, sharp cookie cutters, piping bags and tips, gel colors, and a scribe tool for royal icing.
Cookie scoops, a silicone mat, a cookie cutter set, vanilla, sprinkles and a favorite cookie recipe written on a card.