Cuisinart 9-Inch Round Cake Pan Best Overall
- Care
- Dishwasher safe; hand wash recommended
- Diameter
- 9 inches
- Material
- Carbon steel with PFAS-free nonstick
- Depth
- 1 3/4 inches
Nine inches across and 1 3/4 inches deep is the size most cookie cake recipes assume, and it is where we start anyone building a birthday-sized cookie. Cuisinart's version is heavy carbon steel with a PFAS-free nonstick coating, and the weight is the first thing you notice: set it on a rack and it stays flat through the oven's cycles instead of popping as it heats.
What we like most is how uneventful a bake in it is. The steel carries heat evenly enough that the middle and the rim brown together, and the coating lets a cooled cookie turn out in one piece — we have flipped one onto a plate and slid it back for frosting without a crack running through the edge. The lower wall also means the dough presses out close to the rim, which gives you the flat top a piped border needs.
Two practical notes from using it. Cookie dough is butter and sugar, and butter grabs even a good nonstick surface, so wipe the pan with shortening before you press the dough in, especially the corner where the base meets the wall. Cleanup is a minute with a sponge; Cuisinart lists the pan as dishwasher safe but recommends hand washing, and we hand wash.
It is also the least expensive pan here, which makes a second one for a two-round cookie cake an easy call. The straight 1 3/4-inch wall gives the cookie a defined edge to run frosting against, and that edge is the difference between a cookie cake and a very large cookie.
What We Like
- Heavy steel bakes evenly edge to center
- Coating releases the round in one piece
- Fits the 9-inch size most recipes assume
Worth Noting
- Shallow wall limits how thick a cookie cake gets
For the classic nine-inch cookie cake, this is the pan we hand people first: even heat, an edge that releases whole, and a price that makes a second one easy.
Check Latest Price