The 6 Best Pans for Sheet Cakes of 2026

A sheet cake is forgiving right up until it isn’t. The pan decides whether the edges set before the center, whether the cake releases in one piece, and whether you’re scrubbing burnt corners at 11 p.m. A good one heats evenly, has deep sides for frosting, and feels sturdy when you carry it to a potluck.

I bake birthday cakes and last-minute brownies in a 9-by-13 often enough to notice straight sides and handles. I’ve baked through 12 rectangular and high-sided sheet cake pans, comparing aluminum with nonstick and 9-by-13s with larger 13-by-18 sheets. I watched how each released a cake, cleaned up, and felt when carried by one corner, and where a lid was included, how easily it came off and whether it stayed tight. The lesson: metal gauge and straight sides matter more than a fancy coating. Thin pans brown unevenly and warp, and a bargain that warps isn’t a bargain. The pans we recommend held up to repeated baking and washing.

Our Top Picks

The Best Pans for Sheet Cakes

1

USA Pan 9 x 13 Rectangular Cake Pan Best Overall

USA Pan rectangular cake pan in aluminized steel with ridged nonstick interior, 9 by 13 inches

Standard 9 x 13 cakes

Bake Score 97/100
Material
Aluminized steel with silicone nonstick
Care
Hand wash
Oven Safe
450 °F
Interior Size
9 x 13 x 2.25 in
View on Amazon

Run a finger across the inside of this pan and you hit ridges, not a flat floor. That corrugated surface is why we keep coming back to it: it lets air move under the batter, and cakes and brownies release with a cleaner bottom than they do from a smooth pan. The first sheet cake we baked in ours came out in one piece with square corners, and a soapy sponge took the rest off in seconds.

The 9 x 13 x 2.25-inch interior is a quarter inch deeper than most rectangular cake pans, which is not a small thing when you pour a standard recipe in and watch it climb. There is room for a taller cake, a thick cheesecake batter, or a batch of cinnamon rolls without crowding the rim. Aluminized steel gives it about two pounds of heft, and a full pan does not buckle when you slide it onto the rack.

What it asks in return is care. The silicone coating is the long game here — these pans can chip and flake at the edges after years of service, and the rolled corners hold water, which is how rust gets started. Rinse it promptly, dry the corners first, and stack nothing heavy inside. We have used pans that cost more and released worse; this one earns its place every time a cake has to come out whole.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only; not dishwasher safe
  • Coating can chip with years of use
Our Verdict

We recommend it as the default for a 9 x 13 sheet cake: deep sides, even heat, and a surface that lets the cake go without a fight.

Check Latest Price
2

Fat Daddio's 9 x 13 Sheet Cake Pan Best Without a Coating

Fat Daddio's anodized aluminum sheet cake pan in silver with straight walls and rolled rim

Coating-free baking

Bake Score 96/100
Material
16-gauge anodized aluminum
Capacity
9.5 cups (2248 ml)
Oven Safe
550 °F
Interior Size
9 x 13 x 2 in
View on Amazon

Nothing is sprayed on this pan. It is one piece of 16-gauge anodized aluminum with straight, unflared walls, and that is exactly what a cake that has to look sharp needs: square corners, vertical sides, and less trimming before the frosting goes on. Bakery supply pans are built on this idea, and one bake explains the reputation.

Aluminum moves heat fast, and the POB-9132 heats and cools quicker than the coated steel pans here, so the edges of a cake stop setting and drying while the middle catches up. It is rated to 550°F, a hundred degrees beyond most nonstick, which makes this the pan we reach for with bar cookies and high-heat bakes. Bare anodized aluminum also does not care about tomato or citrus the way a coating does.

What you give up is release. Bare metal is not nonstick, so we grease and line this pan every time: a parchment sling, or butter and flour, not a quick spray. Brownies are the tell — skip the lining and they grip. The gauge is sturdy but not armored, so it scratches if you cut inside it and dents if you stack it carelessly.

Worth Noting

  • Needs greasing and lining before every bake
  • Uncoated surface scratches and dents
Our Verdict

We point anyone who distrusts nonstick coatings to this pan; the trade is that you grease and line it every single time.

Check Latest Price
3

Nordic Ware Prism 13 x 18 Sheet Pan Best for a Crowd

Nordic Ware Prism high-sided sheet cake pan in natural aluminum with a ridged base

Big-batch sheet cakes

Bake Score 95/100
Material
Natural aluminum
Size
13 x 18 x 2 in
Weight
1.8 lb
Surface
Prism textured base
View on Amazon

Thirteen by eighteen inches is half-sheet territory, and it changes what a sheet cake can be. This pan holds roughly double what a 9 x 13 does, so a double batch goes in as one bake — one layer to cool, one pan to frost, no juggling racks in a hot kitchen.

Two inches of side wall is the number that matters, and this is the pan we take to a potluck. A rimmed cookie sheet with the same footprint cannot hold batter, and plenty of big pans are only an inch deep. The prism pattern is there for airflow, and it makes the pan feel stiffer than a flat sheet of the same gauge; a wet, heavy batter does not bow it. Line it with parchment — the ridges catch crumbs, and the paper lets you lift the whole slab out.

The catch is that a standard 9 x 13 recipe bakes thin and fast across this much floor. Use a recipe written for a half sheet, or double what you normally make, and you get a proper thick slab with enough surface to decorate. It earns its storage space the rest of the year on roast vegetables and sheet-pan dinners, which is more than most single-job pans can say.

Worth Noting

  • Ridged base catches crumbs; line with parchment
  • A 9 x 13 recipe bakes thin in this footprint
Our Verdict

We reach for this one when the cake is for a crowd; the 13 x 18 footprint turns a double batch into a single bake.

Check Latest Price
4

Nordic Ware High-Sided Sheet Cake Pan with Lid Best for Baking Ahead

Nordic Ware high-sided aluminum sheet cake pan with a BPA-free plastic storage lid

Baking ahead and traveling

Bake Score 94/100
Material
Natural aluminum
Care
Hand wash
Interior Size
16.5 x 11.38 x 2 in
Included
BPA-free storage lid
View on Amazon

A sheet cake usually gets eaten somewhere other than the counter it was frosted on. This pan comes with a tall, BPA-free plastic lid that clears a frosted top, so the cake can sit in the fridge overnight or ride in the back seat without foil pressed into the buttercream. Between bakes we have used the pan as a proofing box for dough, which turned out to be a second job we did not expect.

Inside, it measures 16.5 by 11.38 inches with 2-inch sides — noticeably bigger than a standard 9 x 13. That brings the usual caveat: a standard recipe spreads thin here. Where the size pays off is the double batch, the Texas sheet cake, and the pan of cinnamon rolls that has to survive a car trip.

For a cake that has to arrive somewhere intact, we have not found a better setup in this group: the lid clears the frosting and the reinforced rim keeps the pan rigid when it is full. The cover rests on the rim rather than snapping down, so carry the whole thing from the pan and keep the lid out of the oven — it is storage, not bakeware. The aluminum is pure, with no coating to flake and no rust to worry about, but it does discolor in the dishwasher, so hand wash it and it stays bright.

Worth Noting

  • Lid rests on the rim instead of locking
  • Not dishwasher safe; aluminum discolors
Our Verdict

Our pick when the cake has to travel or sit in the fridge overnight; the lid is the whole point, even though it rests rather than locks.

Check Latest Price
5

Farberware 9 x 13 Cake Pan Best Budget

Farberware gray nonstick rectangular cake pan, 9 by 13 inches, with rolled handles

A second pan on a budget

Bake Score 93/100
Material
Nonstick-coated steel
Care
Dishwasher safe
Size
9 x 13 in, 2 in deep
Capacity
12 cups
View on Amazon

Every kitchen ends up needing a second 9 x 13, and this is the pan we buy for the job. It is the least expensive one in this group, it is 2 inches deep, and it bakes a level cake with straight edges — the basics done properly, with something left over for the frosting.

It is also the only pan here that goes in the dishwasher, which matters more than it sounds on a night when you are baking two batches back to back. The nonstick is made without PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium. One thing to know before ordering: the 9.8 by 15.6-inch measurement includes the handles, so measure your oven rack and your cupboard, not just the cake.

What you do not get is heft. At about a pound and a half the steel is thinner than the top pick's, and you feel that in the hand rather than in the cake — this is the pan we hand to whoever is helping. For brownies, bar cookies, and weeknight sheet cakes, that is the right trade.

Worth Noting

  • Lighter steel than the premium pans
Our Verdict

Our budget pick: a level 9 x 13 bake, a nonstick surface, and the only pan here you can put in the dishwasher.

Check Latest Price
6

Wilton 11 x 15 Sheet Cake Pan Best for In-Between Cake Sizes

Wilton anodized aluminum sheet cake pan, 11 by 15 inches, with straight sides

In-between cake sizes

Bake Score 92/100
Material
Anodized aluminum
Size
11 x 15 x 2 in
Capacity
11 cups
Oven Safe
450 °F
View on Amazon

Eleven by fifteen is the size to think about when 9 x 13 keeps coming up short and 13 x 18 will not fit. It is a Wilton standard, about 40 percent more floor than a rectangular cake pan, and it is the biggest pan here that still slides into a compact oven. Straight anodized walls give clean sides, which is most of what decorating a sheet cake asks for.

The catch is gauge. At just over ten ounces this is the lightest pan in the group, and thin aluminum tells on itself: ours picked up a ding in a stack of sheet pans, and it will dent if you knock it against the sink. The ding has not changed how it bakes, but it is a reminder to store this one on top of the pile.

The surface is bare anodized aluminum with no coating, so it needs greasing and a parchment sling and it will never peel. Rated to 450°F and made without PFAS. It is the pan we pull out for brownies that have to feed a table without leaving half a pan behind — a size nothing else here covers.

Worth Noting

  • Light aluminum dents easily
  • Bare surface needs greasing and lining
Our Verdict

We like the 11 x 15 size for a bigger cake that still fits a compact oven; just expect a light pan that dents.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested Sheet Cake Pans

We built the shortlist by researching bakeware specs, owner reviews, and the sizes that show up in everyday sheet-cake recipes—mostly 9-by-13, 11-by-15, and larger 13-by-18 pans—then filtering out anything with sides under 2 inches, hollow-feeling handles, or coatings that reviewers said scratched early. From that pool, we tested 12 pans over three months.

Testing happened in a home kitchen, not a lab. I baked sheet cakes, brownies, and the occasional casserole in them, using weekend birthdays, a bake sale, and a potluck as deadlines; I carried each pan by one corner to see whether it flexed and set it down on a hot rack to check for warping. After each bake, I either ran the pan through the dishwasher when the maker allowed it or hand-washed it, noting whether frosting and browned edges lifted off without soaking.

For even heating, I checked whether the center and corners browned at the same rate and whether butter-based batters pulled away from the sides cleanly. For nonstick, I baked one batch without greasing and noted whether the cake released in one piece or left a crust behind, then washed the pan and checked for scratches. For size, I measured interior dimensions and side depth; for the pans that came with lids, I checked how easily the lid came off without tearing frosting and whether it stayed tight when I carried the pan by the handle. At the end, I compared how each pan looked and performed after repeated washes—a pan that warped or scratched moved down the list no matter how well it released the first cake, which is how value shook out.

How to Choose a Pan for Sheet Cakes

Match the footprint to your recipes

Most sheet cake recipes are written for a 9 x 13 pan holding around 12 cups of batter. Pour that same batter into an 11 x 15 or a 13 x 18 and you get a thinner slab that bakes faster and browns harder — not a ruined cake, but a different one. If most of your recipes say 9 x 13, buy 9 x 13; a bigger pan is a commitment to bigger batches.

Depth matters just as much as footprint. Two inches is the working minimum for cake batter, and a 1-inch pan is a jelly roll pan, whatever the listing calls it. The USA Pan's extra quarter inch is the reason a standard recipe does not crowd its rim.

Coated steel or bare aluminum

A nonstick coating buys release and an easy cleanup, and it is also the part that eventually wears out. Keep metal utensils and the dishwasher away from a coated pan and it lasts far longer than one that gets scraped and washed hot. Bare anodized aluminum can't peel, takes higher heat, and shrugs off tomato and citrus, but you grease and line it every single time.

Our split: for a cake you frost and serve from the pan, we like the coating; for brownies and bar cookies cut in the pan, bare aluminum gives cleaner squares.

Measure the outside, not the cake

Listed dimensions are not always the cake size. Handles, rolled rims, and lids add an inch or two per side — the Farberware pan measures 9.8 by 15.6 inches on the outside for a 9 x 13 interior. Measure your oven rack, the shelf above it, and the cupboard where the pan will live.

A 13 x 18 pan needs a wide oven and a sink big enough to wash it. That is the point where a good pan becomes a nuisance you stop using.

Lids, cleanup, and everyday handling

A lid earns its price if cakes leave the house: it clears frosting, stacks, and keeps a cut cake from drying out. Treat it as storage only, since plastic covers do not go in the oven.

Check the care instructions before you commit. Pure aluminum discolor in a dishwasher, coated pans last longer hand-washed, and only one pan in this group is dishwasher safe at all. Dry the rolled rims first — that is where rust starts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

We recommend the USA Pan 9 x 13 for most sheet cakes. The ridged nonstick surface lets a cake go in one piece, the 2.25-inch sides leave room for a taller bake than the standard pan, and the steel is heavy enough to hold an even bake.

If you want to skip coatings entirely, the Fat Daddio's does the same work in bare anodized aluminum — just allow the extra minute for greasing and parchment. And when the cake has to leave the kitchen, the Nordic Ware pan with the lid is the one we pack.