Northriver Casting 9x5 Cast Iron Loaf Pan Set Best Overall
- Weight
- 10 lb
- Pan Size
- 9.1 x 5 x 2.75 in
- Capacity
- 3.4 quarts
- Configuration
- Two stackable pans with lid
Two 9-by-5 pans that clamp together into one lidded baker is the entire idea here, and it is why this is the set we recommend first. Baked open, they are a pair of standard loaf pans, so a double batch of banana bread goes in at once instead of in shifts. Clamped shut, the top half traps steam the way a Dutch oven does, and the loaf comes out rectangular, long enough to slice for sandwiches, with a thin glossy crust an open pan cannot give you.
Size is what settled it for us. American bread recipes are written for 9 by 5, and this pan matches that to within a tenth of an inch, so dough that fills a metal pan to the rim rises here instead of spilling over. The walls are thick enough to hold heat through the cold start of a sourdough bake, and the base and sides brown at the same rate, which is the whole reason to bake in cast iron rather than thin steel.
The trade-offs are the usual ones for bare iron plus one that comes with any lidded set. These arrive unoiled rather than factory-seasoned, so wash them, dry them on low heat and give them a coat of oil before the first loaf. Assembled, the set weighs 10 pounds, and seating the lid squarely on a hot pan takes two hands and dry mitts. The curved handles help, and the halves nest with the lid on top, taking barely more shelf space than a single pan.
What We Like
- Two standard 9-by-5 pans in one set
- Lid traps steam for a crisp crust
- Halves stack into one shelf slot
Worth Noting
- Lid takes two hands to seat hot
- 10 pounds assembled, a chore to lift
We recommend this set to anyone who bakes bread often: you get two standard 9-by-5 pans, a steam lid when you clamp them, and one compact stack to store.
Check Latest Price