Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet 2-Pack Best Overall
- Material
- Pure aluminum
- Count
- 2 pans
- Rim
- Encapsulated galvanized steel
- Exterior Size
- 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 inches
A sheet pan earns its place by staying flat, and the Nordic Ware half sheet has the one piece of construction we look for first: an encapsulated galvanized steel rim rolled around the edge. Aluminum on its own is soft. Put a rigid steel core in the rim and the pan keeps its shape when the metal expands in a hot oven, which is the difference between a tray that sits level and one that bangs against the oven wall.
That rim is the part we trust most here, because everything else about the pan is deliberately plain: no coating, no chemical finish, just bare aluminum, which conducts heat faster than steel and browns a whole sheet of cookies evenly. The interior measures 17.1 by 12.1 inches with a 1-inch rim, so standard half-sheet parchment, silicone mats, and cooling racks drop straight in. Two pans in the box means one can be cooling while the other bakes.
Bare aluminum darkens. Expect a mottled, brownish film after the first high-heat roast, and expect it to keep darkening, because that is oxidized metal rather than damage and the pan bakes exactly the same. Keep it out of the dishwasher, since detergent speeds the process along, and line it with parchment for high-sugar bakes that would otherwise fuse to the surface. A lifetime limited warranty backs the pair, which is a lot of promise for two unglamorous trays.
What We Like
- Two pans for about what one coated set costs
- Encapsulated steel rim keeps both pans flat
- Bare aluminum browns evenly with no coating to chip
- True half-sheet size fits standard mats and racks
Worth Noting
- Shallow 1-inch rim holds less than a deep pan
Our pick for most kitchens: bare aluminum that browns evenly, encapsulated steel rims that stay flat, and no coating to chip or peel. Two pans make it easy.
Check Latest Price