Cuisinart Chef's Classic 9x9 Best Overall
- Care
- Dishwasher safe
- Material
- Aluminized steel
- Oven Safe
- 450 °F
- Baking Surface
- 9 x 9 in, 2 in deep
Recipes assume a 9-inch square of actual baking surface, and that is the first thing we check on any pan that claims the size. The Cuisinart Chef's Classic gives you 9 x 9 inches across the base with 2-inch walls, so a batch of brownies or a coffee cake fills the pan to the depth the recipe expects. It sounds like a small thing until you have baked a 9x9 recipe in a pan that runs small and pulled out bars that are twice as thick and raw in the middle.
Heavy-gauge aluminized steel is why we trust it with an even bake. The metal spreads heat across the base instead of letting the center lag, and the rolled rims hold the pan flat so it doesn't pop and twist the moment it hits a hot oven. Our brownies came out set at the edges without turning brittle, and the corners didn't scorch before the middle firmed up. The nonstick covers the outside as well as the inside, which keeps the pan looking tidy instead of collecting a baked-on brown shell.
Release is genuinely clean — bar cookies have come out in one piece with nothing more than a swipe of butter — and Cuisinart lists the pan as dishwasher safe, which it came through without dulling or spotting. The lifetime warranty is the part we didn't expect; that is rare coverage on a pan in this price bracket.
Set it beside the other picks and the trade is corners: the USA Pan gives you sharp square interior corners for cleaner bar edges, and the Nordic Ware adds a lid. Neither bakes more evenly, and neither comes with a lifetime warranty.
What We Like
- True 9 x 9 baking surface with 2-inch walls
- Even browning from heavy-gauge aluminized steel
- Nonstick inside and out, dishwasher safe
Worth Noting
- Water can pool under the rolled rim
We recommend the Cuisinart Chef's Classic to any baker who wants one square pan that bakes evenly, releases cleanly, and asks nothing of them.
Check Latest Price