Nordic Ware Naturals Jelly Roll Pan Best Overall
- Material
- Pure aluminum, uncoated
- Exterior Dimensions
- 11.3 x 15.8 x 1 inches
- Care
- Hand wash
- Cooking Surface
- 10.5 x 15 inches
Bare aluminum with nothing sprayed or baked onto it is the whole argument for the Nordic Ware Naturals pan, and it is why this one sits at the top of our list. Aluminum moves heat faster and more evenly than the steel blends under most nonstick coatings, so a thin sponge sets at the same rate in the middle as it does at the corners. The cooking surface measures 10.5 by 15 inches, the standard jelly roll footprint, inside an exterior of 11.3 by 15.8 by 1 inch that also slides into a European-size or countertop oven.
The rim is a steel band encapsulated in the aluminum, and you can feel why that matters when you lift a corner with a full batter in the pan: it stays flat instead of oil-canning. We line ours with parchment for sponges mainly because the overhang gives you handles to lift the cake out, and the bare surface takes a smear of butter for cookies without any fuss.
What you give up is convenience. There is no nonstick layer, so nothing releases on its own, and the pan is hand wash only, because the dishwasher leaves the aluminum chalky and dark. It also stains: cocoa, tomato, and lemon all leave their mark, though the marks don't change how it bakes. The two-pack costs more than one coated pan here, and it's worth it, both for the second pan when you bake rolls in sequence and for the fact that there is no coating that can start lifting at the rim.
What We Like
- Bare aluminum with no coating to peel
- Even browning across sponges and cookies
- Two pans per pack for back-to-back batches
Worth Noting
- Hand wash only; dishwasher dulls the finish
- Nothing releases on its own without a liner
Our top pick: two bare-aluminum pans that bake evenly, take parchment happily, and have no coating to chip, for bakers who prefer lining a pan to replacing one.
Check Latest Price