Proctor Silex 18 Quart Roaster Oven Best Overall
- Capacity
- 18 quarts
- Whole Turkey
- Up to 24 lb
- Temperature Range
- 125-450 °F
- Height
- 12.93 inches
Coating is what fails on a roaster oven: enamel chips off the lid, rust creeps around the rim, paint lifts off the pan after a couple of holidays. The Proctor Silex is one of the few big-capacity models in this group that has not built that history, and that is most of the reason it leads our list.
The rest of the case is geometry. This is an 18-quart oven rated for a 24-pound bird that stands 12.93 inches tall with the lid on, which makes it shorter than every domed 26-, 28-, and 30-quart model here. That is what lets it slide under an upper cabinet instead of living on a closet floor. If your kitchen is short on counter and you still want to roast the turkey, that combination is the whole argument.
The thermostat runs 125 to 450 °F, and that low end sits about 25 degrees below most of the field, so you get a genuine slow-roast setting instead of a warm hold that scorches the bottom of the pan. The control is a plain analog knob with no readout, so put an oven thermometer on the rack for the first few cooks and learn your unit's offset. After that you will trust it.
Getting a hot 24-pounder out is where these ovens usually go wrong, and the lift-out rack with handles is the fix: you pull straight up and the bird comes with you. The pan lifts out too, so cleanup is a sink job rather than a reach-into-the-cavity job.
Eighteen quarts is the honest limit. With a big bird in the well there is no room left for the potatoes, and the Hamilton Beach gives you more elbow room in a similar footprint. Buy this one for the turkey and hand everything else to the wall oven it just freed up.
What We Like
- 24-pound rating in a 12.93-inch-tall body
- 125-450 °F range, the widest here
- No chipping-enamel pattern in its history
- Removable pan and handled lift-out rack
Worth Noting
- 18 quarts leaves no room for sides
- Analog knob with no digital readout
Buy this one: a 24-pound bird in a 13-inch-tall body, the widest thermostat in the group, and none of the chipping-coating history that dogs the rest.
Check Latest Price