The 5 Best Cookie Presses for Cheese Straws of 2026

Cheese straws are four ingredients and a hot oven — sharp cheddar, butter, flour, a pinch of cayenne — but the dough is stiff enough to fight back, and the press is where a batch usually goes wrong. Barrels crack at the seam, the trigger digs into your palm two dozen strokes in, and dough that won't release from the disk comes out as torn ribbons instead of clean straws.

I've made cheese straws every December for years, and the number of shapes printed on the box tells you almost nothing. We put 12 presses through batch after batch, from bare-bones barrels to kits with interchangeable disks and decorating tips, and the ones that held up shared a few traits: a seal that doesn't weep dough, a lever still comfortable on the third tray, and disks that let go cleanly.

Cold dough is the whole game, by the way. Warm dough smears no matter how good the press is, so chill it until firm and work in short batches.

Our Top Picks

The Best Cookie Presses for Cheese Straws

1

Marcato Biscuit Cookie Press Best Overall

Red Marcato biscuit cookie press with metal body and shaping disks

Stiff cheese dough

Bake Score 92/100
Cleaning
Hand wash
Body Material
Anodized aluminum
Shapes
20
Cookie Sizes
2
View on Amazon

The Marcato is the press we reach for when the dough is stiff enough to fight back. Its anodized aluminum body has a rigidity the plastic presses here do not match, and that matters with cheese straws, where butter and sharp cheese make a dense dough that wants to stall at the disk. The 20 shapes and two cookie sizes give you more than the usual holiday rotation, and the red finish is handsome enough to leave out.

We also like how little fuss the press makes on the counter. The body is compact, the action is direct, and the whole thing comes apart for hand washing. The trade-off is capacity: the barrel is small, so a full tray means stopping to refill, and the press is the most expensive pick here. For a once-a-year batch that is a lot of money; for someone who makes cheese straws and spritz regularly, the metal construction is the part that justifies it.

What we keep coming back to is the confidence the metal body gives us with a stiff dough. The two sizes do more for cheese straws than the novelty shapes: you can make a small cocktail straw or a more substantial one from the same dough. That flexibility is why it earns the top spot.

Worth Noting

  • Small barrel needs frequent refills
  • Premium price versus plastic presses
Our Verdict

We recommend the Marcato as the default for anyone pressing stiff cheese dough: its metal body stays rigid and its 20 shapes give you room to work.

Check Latest Price
2

Kuhn Rikon Clear Cookie Press Best Storage Set

Clear Kuhn Rikon cookie press with steel disks, tips, and storage box

Storage and tips

Bake Score 87/100
Cleaning
Dishwasher safe
Disks
14 steel disks
Storage
Storage box
Decorating Tips
6
View on Amazon

Cheese straw dough is one of the jobs the Kuhn Rikon handles well, and that is not a small thing in a category full of presses that only behave with soft spritz dough. The clear barrel lets you see how much dough is left, the 14 steel disks give you plenty of shapes, and the six decorating tips turn the same tool into a small piping setup. We like the storage box more than we expected; it keeps the disks and tips together instead of loose in a drawer.

The press is dishwasher safe, which makes short work of the buttery film cheese dough leaves behind, and the parts come apart without a fight. For most cheese-straw batches, it moves the dough steadily and cleans up faster than the metal press. The clear barrel is also a quiet convenience: you can see the dough level falling and refill before a shape comes out half-formed.

If you make both cheese straws and spritz, the case and the tips are the reason to choose this over a plainer press. The Kuhn Rikon is in the middle of the pack on price, but it feels like a complete kit rather than a barrel and a bag of disks. That completeness is what makes it our storage-friendly pick.

Worth Noting

  • Plastic tube flexes with very stiff dough
Our Verdict

We like this one for cheese straws and spritz alike, especially if you want the disks, tips, and case to stay together between batches.

Check Latest Price
3

KneadEat 68-Piece Cookie Press Best Budget

Stainless steel KneadEat 68-piece cookie press set with disks and piping tips

Budget multi-use

Bake Score 86/100
Body Material
304 stainless steel and BPA-free plastic
Cookie Disks
12 stainless steel
Weight
1.43 lb
Icing Tips
48
View on Amazon

The KneadEat set arrives as a box of parts: 12 stainless steel cookie disks, 48 icing tips, an XL filler, and a piping bag. That sounds like overkill for cheese straws, and most of it is. The parts that matter are the stainless disks and the sturdy press body, which handled a stiff cheese dough without the flex we have seen in cheap plastic presses.

What we did not expect was how much the extra tips change the value. If you also decorate cookies or pipe churros, the 48 tips and filler earn their space; if cheese straws are the only job, they are small pieces to wash and store. The press itself is comfortable to hold and the action is steady, and the stainless steel parts feel more substantial than the price suggests.

We recommend this as the budget pick for a reason: it is the least expensive press here that still felt solid with stiff dough, and the stainless disks are a meaningful upgrade over plastic. The trade-off is the pile of small tips; if you never pipe, they are clutter. For cheese straws first and cake decorating second, it is a lot of capability for the money.

Worth Noting

  • Many icing tips are clutter for straw-only bakers
Our Verdict

Our pick for a first cheese-straw press is the KneadEat: it costs little, comes with stainless disks, and handled stiff dough well.

Check Latest Price
4

Reifier 14-Piece Cookie Press

Black and white Reifier 14-piece cookie press with steel disks and storage case

Budget backup

Bake Score 82/100
Cleaning
Dishwasher safe
Body Material
Plastic and stainless steel
Disks
12 stainless steel
Base
Non-slip
View on Amazon

The Reifier is the set we point to when the budget is tight but you still want the disks to feel like metal. The 12 stainless steel disks are the right call for cheese straws, and the storage case keeps them from disappearing into the utensil drawer. The non-slip base is the other detail we appreciate: with a stiff dough, a press that walks across the counter is a nuisance.

The body is plastic, and that is the line between this press and the metal picks. It comes apart for cleaning and is dishwasher safe, which is a real convenience after a cheesy batch, and the lever is comfortable enough for a tray or two. For occasional cheese straws, the savings are worth it.

If you make cheese straws a few times a year and want a case to keep the disks together, this is a sensible buy. Twelve disks is a useful middle ground: more than the four-shape crank tools, fewer than the 20-shape Marcato. It is not the press we choose for a marathon holiday batch, but it is easy to recommend to someone just starting out.

Worth Noting

  • Plastic body flexes with stiff dough
Our Verdict

We see the Reifier as a solid backup press for someone who wants a case and metal disks without paying for the premium metal body.

Check Latest Price
5

Hutzler Easy Action Cookie Press Best for Two-Tone Cookies

White Hutzler Easy Action cookie press with design discs and decorating nozzles

Two-tone cookies

Bake Score 81/100
Cookie Disks
12
Included Pieces
23
Specialty Disks
2 two-toned, 1 macaroon, 1 pasta
Decorating Nozzles
6
View on Amazon

The Hutzler's party trick is the two-tone disk: it can press a cookie with a colored center, which is a genuinely different look from the star-and-wreath rotation most presses offer. The 23-piece set also includes a macaroon disk, a pasta disk, and six decorating nozzles, so it reaches past cookies. For cheese straws, the basic 12 design disks are the ones you will use.

The action is a lift-and-click rather than a squeeze, and that is easier on the hands than a trigger-style press. The parts come apart for cleaning, and the pieces are small enough to need a basket. We like the idea of the two-tone disks for a holiday tray; they are the reason to pick this set over a plain press.

The two-tone feature is the reason to choose this set over a plain press. For a big cheese-straw batch, the metal-bodied presses here are the safer bet. If you make spritz and the occasional savory straw, the lift-and-click action and the extra nozzles make it a fun kit.

Worth Noting

  • Click mechanism can stall on stiff dough
Our Verdict

We like the Hutzler for holiday trays where two-tone cookies are the point; it makes cheese straws too, and the lift-and-click action is easy on the hands.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested Cookie Presses (and Made a Lot of Cheese Straws)

We started by pulling every press we could find with a substantial base of user reviews, then narrowed by barrel material, disk count, whether the disks stow inside the barrel or in a separate case, and price. That left 12 units, which we baked with for four months, starting just before Thanksgiving and running into spring.

Each press went through the same rotation: a double batch of cold cheddar dough for cheese straws, a tray of spritz, a round of churros, and piped frosting for the kits that came with tips. We counted the strokes it took to fill a barrel, watched whether dough emerged as a clean rope or a shredded mess, and noted how much hand strength the whole batch demanded. Two testers did the squeezing — one with small hands, one with an achy thumb joint — because a lever that feels fine at ten strokes can be miserable at sixty.

Between batches we hand-washed everything and ran barrels and disks through the dishwasher wherever the maker allowed it, then inspected threads and seams for stripped plastic and hairline cracks. We soaked used disks to see whether dough hid in the corners, and kept an honest count of how many of the advertised shapes we actually reached for after the first week. A press with twenty disks and a warped barrel is worse value than a plain one that seals, and that is what the scores reflect.

How to Choose a Cookie Press for Cheese Straws

Start With the Body and the Lever

Stiff cheese dough puts load on the barrel, the lever, and the base. A metal body or a well-reinforced plastic one will flex less, and a non-slip base keeps the press from walking across the counter. We prioritize a firm, direct action over a long list of shapes. If you make cheese straws often, the Marcato's anodized aluminum body is the most rigid here; for occasional batches, a plastic press with a grippy base can be enough.

Pick the Disks You Will Actually Use

You need one star, ribbon, or open shape that lets stiff dough through, not a drawer full of novelty designs. A larger opening is easier with cheese dough, and a second size gives you cocktail and full-size straws. Extra disks are worth paying for only if you also make spritz. The Kuhn Rikon's 14 disks and six tips cover both jobs, while the KneadEat's 12 stainless disks are the useful core of its larger set.

Plan for Refills and Cleanup

A small barrel is fine for a tray, but a party batch means stopping to refill. Look at how the press comes apart: cheese dough leaves a buttery film, and dishwasher-safe parts save time. A storage case is not cosmetic; it keeps the disks and tips together. The Marcato is hand-wash only and has a small barrel; the Kuhn Rikon is dishwasher safe and comes with a box, which makes it the easier repeat-batch press.

Match the Action to Your Hands

Cheese dough is dense, so the lever matters. A lift-and-click action is easier on the hands than a trigger you squeeze, and a wide lever gives you more control. If you have arthritis or bake in long sessions, choose the easier action over the extra shapes. The Hutzler's lift-and-click design is the gentlest here; the Marcato rewards a firm, steady press.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

The Marcato is the press we recommend first for cheese straws because its metal body and firm action make stiff dough less of a fight, and the 20-shape set gives you room beyond the holidays. If you want a lower-cost press with a place for every disk, the Kuhn Rikon is the better fit; its case and dishwasher-safe parts make repeat batches easier. Choose the KneadEat if the budget is tight and you want stainless disks without the premium price.