OXO Good Grips 5.0 Qt POP Cookie Jar Best Overall
- Capacity
- 5 quarts
- Seal
- Push-button airtight
- Care
- Gasket dishwasher safe
- Material
- BPA-free plastic
The lid is the whole reason this jar is our top pick. Press the button, the seal lets go, and the button turns into a handle you lift the lid by — one motion, one hand, no prying at a glass rim. It is simple enough that a three-year-old can work it alone, and that is the detail that decides whether a cookie jar gets used or turns into a decoration with crumbs in the bottom.
Five quarts is the number that matters after the lid. That is more than a gallon, enough for a party-size bag of sandwich cookies with room left over or a six-pound bag of kibble, and the circular opening is wide enough to get a whole hand in rather than fishing with your fingertips. We also came to appreciate the flat back: the jar sits flush against the backsplash instead of leaving a dead corner behind it that nobody wipes.
Airtight is easy to print on a package and harder to live up to, and this one holds. Cookies come out soft close to two weeks later, and the same seal keeps strong-smelling contents from announcing themselves every time the pantry door opens. The silicone gasket pops out of the lid for washing; everything else in the jar is hand wash, which is the only real chore it adds to your week.
Open the box the day it arrives and confirm the lid is in there, since it ships as a separate piece and it is the one part that goes missing. And go in clear-eyed about the look: this is plastic that reads as plastic. That is the trade for a jar that seals this well and opens this easily — the glass picks below are for the counter you style, this one is for the counter you work on.
What We Like
- One-handed push-button seal
- Five quarts holds bulk bags
- Simple enough for a child to open
Worth Noting
- Body and lid are hand wash only
- Plastic looks utilitarian next to glass
Our pick for most kitchens: five quarts, a push-button seal that opens one-handed, and a lid a child can work alone.
Check Latest Price