Fire More Ceramic Baking Sheet Set Best Overall
- Set Includes
- Half sheet, jelly roll, and quarter pans plus cooling rack
- Coating
- Ceramic nonstick, PFOA and PTFE free
- Pan Sizes
- 12/16/18 inch
- Steel Thickness
- 0.8 mm carbon steel
Three pans and a rack come in the box: a half sheet, a jelly roll pan, and a quarter sheet. That's the reason this set is our top pick. The half sheet handles a tray of cookies or a sheet-pan dinner, the quarter sheet is right for two chicken thighs or a small batch of granola, and the jelly roll pan has the deeper rim you want when something bubbles.
The ceramic coating is what changes a weeknight. Cookies slide off with a nudge, roasted vegetables leave a film rather than a crust, and cleanup is a soapy sponge instead of a soak. The diamond-patterned surface lifts food slightly off the pan so fat and air can move underneath, which shows up in crisper edges on potatoes and chickpeas.
At 0.8 mm, the steel is thicker than the flimsy sheets that buckle the first time you roast at 425°F. It's one of two 0.8 mm sets here, and it stayed flat through our testing, with no popping or twisting as it came up to heat. Thickness is the number we care about most in this category, because warping ends a pan's useful life long before the coating wears out.
The rolled rim is the one spot to baby. Water collects in that fold, so dry these by hand instead of leaving them in the rack — it's the difference between years of service and a rust line along the edge.
What We Like
- Three useful pan sizes plus a cooling rack
- Ceramic coating releases food and wipes clean
- 0.8 mm steel resists warping better than thin sheets
Worth Noting
- Only one cooling rack for three pans
The set we recommend to most bakers: three ceramic-coated pans, a cooling rack, and thick 0.8 mm steel that stayed flat in our testing.
Check Latest Price