Nordic Ware Naturals 3-Piece Set Best Overall
- Material
- Pure aluminum
- Pans In Set
- Half, jelly roll, quarter
- Rim
- Encapsulated galvanized steel
- Warranty
- Lifetime
Bare aluminum is the whole argument for this set. There is no coating to chip, peel, or scrub around, so what you get on day one is what you get in five years, and the pans brown cookies evenly right out to the edges. The encapsulated galvanized steel rim does the quiet work: we have run these through high-heat roasting and sheet-pan dinners without the buckle and pop that thinner pans give you. That combination, even browning and a pan that stays flat, is what we want from a baking sheet, and nothing else here does both as well.
The three sizes are the other reason it earns the top spot. The half sheet takes a full batch of cookies or a chicken-and-vegetable dinner, the jelly roll pan is built for bars and rolled cakes, and the quarter sheet has become the one we reach for most, since it fits a toaster oven, holds two chicken breasts, and rinses in seconds. They nest, so three pans take the drawer space of one.
Aluminum is reactive and it darkens with use, so keep tomatoes and lemon off it for long stretches and expect a patina that some cooks like and others do not. We have found that a paste of baking soda lifts stubborn browned spots without scratching. None of that changes how the pan bakes, which is the point of buying bare metal in the first place.
What We Like
- No coating to chip or peel
- Encapsulated steel rim resists warping
- Half, jelly roll, and quarter sizes
- Even, gentle browning
Worth Noting
- Hand wash only; the dishwasher dulls it
- Can arrive scuffed or dented
We recommend this trio to anyone who wants even browning and pans that stay flat, and who doesn't mind hand washing aluminum.
Check Latest Price