Rachael Ray Nonstick Baking Pan with Lid Best Overall
- Material
- Heavy-gauge steel
- Size
- 9" x 13"
- Oven Safe
- 500 °F
- Dishwasher
- Pan and lid
Two features decided this one for us: the lid presses down over the rim and holds, and the pan and lid are both dishwasher safe. That second point is rarer than it sounds in a category full of hand-wash-only aluminum, and it is the difference between a pan you use on a Tuesday and one that waits for the weekend. The oven rating is the highest in this group, too, so it doubles as a roasting pan between cakes.
Baking is even and uneventful, which is the goal: heavy-gauge steel, a dark nonstick coating that let brownies and a scratch-made sheet cake out without parchment, and a body rigid enough that we could lift a full lasagna by one end without the pan bowing. The rubberized handles are the detail we did not expect to care about. They gave us a real grip on a full pan, and we noticed that more than any of the finish details.
The lid is the whole reason you are shopping for a set like this. It seals hard enough to carry a frosted cake across town without a wobble, and the dome sits high enough that a swirl of buttercream does not get scraped off when you put it on. It stacks flat, too, so a second pan or a container of leftovers can sit on top in the fridge.
The nonstick is the part that ages. Keep metal spatulas and scrubby sponges out of it, wash the coated side by hand when the sink is free, and it will look new for a long stretch. What you pay for over the budget pick is that lid and fifty more degrees of oven headroom, and for a pan that goes from oven to fridge to potluck, that is a fair trade.
What We Like
- Lid seals tightly enough to carry a cake
- Pan and lid are both dishwasher safe
- Oven safe to 500 °F, the highest rating here
- Rubberized handles give a confident grip
Worth Noting
- Lid needs a firm pull to release
The one we hand to anyone who bakes a cake and then has to move it: the lid clamps down, the handles hold, and pan and lid both go in the dishwasher.
Check Latest Price